Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

If you're looking for a place to direct your vehicular thoughts, you've found it.

Moderator: Monochrome

Post Reply
User avatar
Jeff V.
Posts: 25401
Joined: Wed Feb 28, 2007 7:36 pm

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Jeff V. »

All I'm pointing out is where to get reference values for the various sensors. How you put the Legos together is up to you.
I think about all the things we could have done, all the miracles we could have achieved, if we were all just a little bit better than it turns out we are.
--Naomi Nagata
User avatar
Monochrome
Founding Members
Founding Members
Posts: 18264
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:16 pm
Location: NE Maryland
Contact:

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Monochrome »

[quote=""ChargerX3""]Exactly it’s a different size and style maf. I’m not trying to be a difficult but are 3.8l MIVEC builds going to be properly represented in this equation?[/quote]

That adder value came from an 03 Padjero running a 6G75 SOHC motor with MIVEC.... So yes.

The MAF Scaling is the exact same as a 3000GT as it runs the same style MAF.

I can get you the MAF size value later tonight if you need it.
Last edited by Monochrome on Fri Aug 16, 2019 10:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
2020 Miata Club - BBS package
2020 GMC Sierra Elevation Duramax
2014 Exomotive Exocet - #101 "shocker yellow" - sold :(
Read more: http://mevowners.proboards.com/thread/5 ... g-pa-build
99 Solano Black VR4 - #16 of 287 - ground up restoration - sold :(

"I don't actually work on cars, I just talk about them on the internet."
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

Sooooo....about my enrichment table?


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
Monochrome
Founding Members
Founding Members
Posts: 18264
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:16 pm
Location: NE Maryland
Contact:

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Monochrome »

[quote=""DCIV""]Sooooo....about my enrichment table?


Coop[/quote]

Which one?
2020 Miata Club - BBS package
2020 GMC Sierra Elevation Duramax
2014 Exomotive Exocet - #101 "shocker yellow" - sold :(
Read more: http://mevowners.proboards.com/thread/5 ... g-pa-build
99 Solano Black VR4 - #16 of 287 - ground up restoration - sold :(

"I don't actually work on cars, I just talk about them on the internet."
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

[quote=""DCIV""]You said the enrichment tables were wrong. I have Messed with these tables to try and cut out extra fuel as I smell fuel heavily only on start up.

What do I need to change in v2 to make it correct and basically 0 enrichment?


Coop[/quote]

This one.


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
ChargerX3
Posts: 12402
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2011 8:51 pm
Location: Reno

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by ChargerX3 »

[quote=""Monochrome""]That adder value came from an 03 Padjero running a 6G75 SOHC motor with MIVEC.... So yes.

The MAF Scaling is the exact same as a 3000GT as it runs the same style MAF.

I can get you the MAF size value later tonight if you need it.[/quote]

Oh, you went overseas on me. Nice!

Proper size would be nice to plug in.
Image
User avatar
Monochrome
Founding Members
Founding Members
Posts: 18264
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:16 pm
Location: NE Maryland
Contact:

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Monochrome »

[quote=""DCIV""]This one.


Coop[/quote]

The ones that were wrong aren’t going to have that kind of affect on your tune. These tables are only effective for a fraction of a second after start up.

Ginger Nate was also complaining to me that his car “runs” rich on startup and wanted to “disable” that. Well... it’s supposed to. Closed loop doesn’t even start till after the excess post start fuel burnt up and the narrowband heaters are warmed up.

If you’re spitting fuel you should cut back the coolant temp fuel enrichment from the fuel section.
Last edited by Monochrome on Sun Aug 18, 2019 4:02 am, edited 3 times in total.
2020 Miata Club - BBS package
2020 GMC Sierra Elevation Duramax
2014 Exomotive Exocet - #101 "shocker yellow" - sold :(
Read more: http://mevowners.proboards.com/thread/5 ... g-pa-build
99 Solano Black VR4 - #16 of 287 - ground up restoration - sold :(

"I don't actually work on cars, I just talk about them on the internet."
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

[quote=""Monochrome""]The ones that were wrong aren’t going to have that kind of affect on your tune. These tables are only effective for a fraction of a second after start up.

Ginger Nate was also complaining to me that his car “runs” rich on startup and wanted to “disable” that. Well... it’s supposed to. Closed loop doesn’t even start till after the excess fuel is post start fuel burnt up and the narrowband heaters are warmed up.

If you’re spitting fuel you should cut back the coolant temp fuel enrichment from the fuel section.[/quote]

I talked to future man a lot about this when I noticed. Maybe that’s why I feel it’s more of an issue than it is.

I messed with the temp/enrichment section. Which is what I think your talking about. Also I may have read your other post wrong about this then.


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
aaronatstate
Posts: 9860
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:52 pm
Location: Arkansas

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by aaronatstate »

Coop do you have catalytic converters still?
Image
Chr15t0ph3r85: YES
Chr15t0ph3r85: GOOO STATE
:)
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

[quote=""aaronatstate""]Coop do you have catalytic converters still?[/quote]

The main. Not the fronts.


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
aaronatstate
Posts: 9860
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:52 pm
Location: Arkansas

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by aaronatstate »

So messed around a bit this morning with the MAF settings.

So I set everything to stock, except for the VE Smoothing table, which I set per Adam's recommendation here.

When I started the car, everything seemed good, except when the car went into closed loop mode, my wideband pegged LEAN and seemed to idle rougher. The car had been idling around 15.5:1 or so. It still seemed to rev OK, but seemed much leaner than it was before the changes.

So I changed the MAF adder back to the Evo setting, 140, and tried again. This time when the car went into closed loop, the idle was back to ~15.5:1 and the car was idling better. It seems like the adder value 100% made the biggest change (at least at idle and rev in the garage).

Right now my settings are stock Scaling and Size, VE Smoothing per Adam's page, and Evo setting for the adder value. I haven't done any driving yet, as I just had a bit of time to mess around in the garage idling.
Image
Chr15t0ph3r85: YES
Chr15t0ph3r85: GOOO STATE
:)
User avatar
aaronatstate
Posts: 9860
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:52 pm
Location: Arkansas

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by aaronatstate »

[quote=""aaronatstate""]So the higher the value in the VE smoothing table, the richer it will run? So I'm probably going to be pig rich on the first go since the values are so much higher than the Evo values. But I assume the size will offset that some.[/quote]

This is 100% true. I did some more messing around. If you want your VE smoothing to be closer to 100, you have to add units to the MAF adder. I got more or less equivalent AFRs with the ~170 VE smoothing and 64 MAF adder (stock ROM values) as I got with the ~100 VE smoothing and 140 MAF adder (Evo Rom values).

This makes sense to me now, because say 100=nominal, so 172 gets you an extra 72 points plus 64 MAF adder points for a total of 236 points. With the Evo values, you get 7 extra points plus 140 MAF adder points for a total of 247 points. Pretty darn close...

Oh and as an FYI, I am getting 2200-2300Hz with my current setup (13t's at 20psi with E85). That was a second gear pull too. Not enough room to do a 3rd gear pull where I went today.
Image
Chr15t0ph3r85: YES
Chr15t0ph3r85: GOOO STATE
:)
User avatar
ChargerX3
Posts: 12402
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2011 8:51 pm
Location: Reno

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by ChargerX3 »

I’m going to need to Sit down and attempt to digest what you just said.
Image
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

[quote=""ChargerX3""]I’m going to need to Sit down and attempt to digest what you just said.[/quote]

You and me both. I wish I understood the tuning aspect more.


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
aaronatstate
Posts: 9860
Joined: Tue Apr 17, 2007 3:52 pm
Location: Arkansas

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by aaronatstate »

[quote=""ChargerX3""]I’m going to need to Sit down and attempt to digest what you just said.[/quote]

[quote=""DCIV""]You and me both. I wish I understood the tuning aspect more.


Coop[/quote]

Assume 100 is baseline.

Stock 3/S values are 172 scaling, and 64 adder, so you get (172/100)*100+64=236

Evo values are 107 scaling, and 140 adder, so you get (107/100)*100+140=247

I tried the stock 3S scaling of 172 and the Evo adder 140 and it ran stupid rich, like 10.5:1 at idle. I assume this gave me like (172/100)*100+140=312.

When I used the Evo scaling of 107 and the 3S adder of 64, it ran stupid lean, like 20:1 at idle (wideband was pegged lean). I assume this gave me like (107/100)*100+64=171.

I could be WAY off, but that’s what I experienced messing with the values.
Image
Chr15t0ph3r85: YES
Chr15t0ph3r85: GOOO STATE
:)
User avatar
ChargerX3
Posts: 12402
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2011 8:51 pm
Location: Reno

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by ChargerX3 »

That was much clearer. So which setting runs best on your build then since the other are way off?
Image
User avatar
DCIV
Posts: 26678
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:14 am
Location: TN

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by DCIV »

And I have a GM mas. So I really have no idea.


Coop
[quote=""Melis""]The cop asked Coop "Are you really a firefighter?" Coop was like "yeah" then the cop said "ok your in charge" then the cop left :lol:
[/quote]

DCIV: first to 2,000,000 rep points :)
User avatar
Monochrome
Founding Members
Founding Members
Posts: 18264
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:16 pm
Location: NE Maryland
Contact:

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Monochrome »

[quote=""aaronatstate""]Assume 100 is baseline.

Stock 3/S values are 172 scaling, and 64 adder, so you get (172/100)*100+64=236

Evo values are 107 scaling, and 140 adder, so you get (107/100)*100+140=247

I tried the stock 3S scaling of 172 and the Evo adder 140 and it ran stupid rich, like 10.5:1 at idle. I assume this gave me like (172/100)*100+140=312.

When I used the Evo scaling of 107 and the 3S adder of 64, it ran stupid lean, like 20:1 at idle (wideband was pegged lean). I assume this gave me like (107/100)*100+64=171.

I could be WAY off, but that’s what I experienced messing with the values.[/quote]



Adding more to the adder value is going to richen the whole MAF range. Adding more to the smoothing table will only richen the mIxture at the HZ range you edited.

Also, there's the fuel side of all this. What injectors are you running and what injector size? Sometimes people running E85 will lower the injector size to get more fuel across the whole range. Same thing you're doing by adding more to the adder value. In fact that's probably smarter anyway!

When tuning E85 cars I completely disable closed loop and tune using only the MAF smoothing tables. Takes a few pulls but when you're done and reenable closed loop, the car runs stock smooth.

Don't let the 172 number in the smoothing table scare you either. I've gone higher than 200 in some tunes. Remember you don't have factory ICs or pipes AND you're running E85 which is 33% MORE fuel by itself.
Last edited by Monochrome on Sun Aug 18, 2019 3:47 am, edited 2 times in total.
2020 Miata Club - BBS package
2020 GMC Sierra Elevation Duramax
2014 Exomotive Exocet - #101 "shocker yellow" - sold :(
Read more: http://mevowners.proboards.com/thread/5 ... g-pa-build
99 Solano Black VR4 - #16 of 287 - ground up restoration - sold :(

"I don't actually work on cars, I just talk about them on the internet."
User avatar
Monochrome
Founding Members
Founding Members
Posts: 18264
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:16 pm
Location: NE Maryland
Contact:

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by Monochrome »

[quote=""ChargerX3""]That was much clearer. So which setting runs best on your build then since the other are way off?[/quote]

You're going to have different results because you will have a completely different setup.
2020 Miata Club - BBS package
2020 GMC Sierra Elevation Duramax
2014 Exomotive Exocet - #101 "shocker yellow" - sold :(
Read more: http://mevowners.proboards.com/thread/5 ... g-pa-build
99 Solano Black VR4 - #16 of 287 - ground up restoration - sold :(

"I don't actually work on cars, I just talk about them on the internet."
User avatar
ChargerX3
Posts: 12402
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2011 8:51 pm
Location: Reno

Re: Chrome V3, need a place to organize my thoughts

Post by ChargerX3 »

[quote=""Monochrome""]You're going to have different results because you will have a completely different setup.[/quote]

Agreed. That wasn’t lost on me, just his process.
Image
Post Reply